Amazon.com Widgets

Sam Winter calls for end to trans psychopathologization

  

In honor of the 2009 Transgender Day of Remembrance, Dr. Sam Winter has just issued a strong appeal for the removal of gender identity variance from the psychiatric diagnostic manuals.

Time is pressing on in the psychopathologisation debate. The WHO and APA proceed in revising ICD and DSM respectively, the increasingly international STP-2012 (Stop Transpathologisation) Campaign gathers force, more and more research articles detail the links in the chain leading from psychopathologisation to illness and death, books on the subject (most recently Kelley Winters’ painstakingly careful analysis) get published..

The issue of psychopathologisation is of course a health issue, in that it is all about the view we take of transpeople’s mental health. But it is a health issue on many more grounds too. The psychopathologisation of GIV and GV engenders stigma, cultivates and/or supports prejudice and discrimination, contributes to social and economic marginalisation and poverty worldwide for transpeople, and is ultimately a health issue, raising the risk of poor mental health and well-being (and self-damaging and suicidal behaviours), social isolation, risk behaviours (including sexual), involvement in prostitution (often through lack of other employment possibilities), and HIV/AIDS risk.

Full article:
http://web.hku.hk/~sjwinter/TransgenderASIA/call-for-depsychopathologisation.htm


This is talk, not advice. See Terms of Use for details.
Posted by Andrea James on 11/20 at 11:34 AM

A good article from Sam Winter sadly goes off the rails right at the end where Sam writes: “ ... remove ... from ... mental disorders, instead providing a diagnostic category elsewhere in ICD ... “.

That part is wrong for several reasons:

1: A new category will not be added anytime soon, at best there might be a recoding away from ICD Chapter V (Mental and Behavioural disorders).

2. If there is anything less than a complete removal then the psychopatholgizers will simply pull a “change the name and continue the game” crime. They really are experts at that game.

3. New diagnoses are not needed, existing diagnoses are sufficient. What is needed is a realization that it is OK (for example) to diagnose a transwoman with ICD Q50.0 (Congenital absence of ovaries) - similar diagnoses will open to transwomen as soon as it becomes impossible to diagnose them as mentally ill men and not before. The 302.85 and F64.0 diagnoses are doing immeasureable harm today and they need to be abolished, not because they are invalid, but because their existence severely damages health. Scientific validity does not justify pervasive damage to health.

Posted by  on  11/20  at  04:21 PM
Page 1 of 1 pages
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

<< Back to main