Steven Pinker on
transsexualism
"The skill of being a good liar is to weave an occasional lie into a
largely truthful matrix, so people won't simply write you off as not worth
paying attention to."
-- Steven Pinker, 8
February 2001
A professor of psychology, Dr. Pinker moved to Harvard in 2003 after 20 years
at MIT working in the Brain and Cognitive Sciences department. He is the author
of many books on mind and language, including The Language Instinct: How the
Mind Creates Language, Words and Rules: The Ingredients of Language, and How
the Mind Works. His writing is also used by J. Michael Bailey in his Human Sexuality
class, and Dr. Pinker is a member of the Human
Biodiversity Institute with Bailey.
Dr. Pinker is quoted twice in Joseph
Henry Press publicity for J Michael Bailey's The Man Who Would Be Queen,
though he's only attributed once. This gives the impression the other review
is from somone else.
http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10530.html
"With a mixture science, humanity, and fine writing, J. Michael Bailey
illuminates the mysteries of sexual orientation and identity in the best book
yet written on the subject. The Man Who Would Be Queen may upset the
guardians of political correctness on both the left and the right, but it
will be welcomed by intellectually curious people of all sexes and sexual
orientations. A truly fascinating book."
-- Steven Pinker, Peter de Florez Professor, MIT, and author of How the
Mind Works and The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature"
J Michael Baileys The Man Who Would Be Queen is an engaging
book on the science of sexual orientation. ...highly sympathetic to gay and
transsexual men..."
-- The Guardian (London), June 28, 2003
http://books.guardian.co.uk/review/story/0,12084,986174,00.html
After my initial attempts to reach Bailey intellectually and emotionally, I
took solace in the words of Professor Pinker, as told to his friend Steve
Sailer at the Human Biodiversity Institute:
"We cannot teach a psychopath that crime is wrong even if no one sees
you commit it. With everyone else, we can appeal to their empathy, alerting
them to the harm they do to other people; to their intellect, pointing out
that they cannot logically hold others to standards that they flout themselves;
and to their sense of character, reminding them that a person of principle
will, in the long run and for good reason, be trusted and esteemed more than
someone who cuts corners whenever he thinks he can get away with it."
Below: Pinker and the Brain plotting their takeover of the intellectual
world.
Other resources:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,3926387,00.html
Steven Pinker argues that much of who we are, our personalities, our intelligence,
our developmental stages are mostly a deep-seated program inherited
through our genes. He says the environments role has been overstated by
left-leaning scientists who would prefer to believe that all of us begin the
same and are then shaped by economic and social circumstances. What, he asks,
if we are all essentially different? His most recent book is The Blank Slate.
Notes to address later:
Affective neuroscience
Sailer reviews Pinker
Pinker computational model of brain
Evidence-based medicine
Duke Center for Clinical Health Policy Research
1) Simon Baron-Cohen, The Essential Difference, The truth about the Male &
Female Brain(Basic Books)
Steven Pinker:"a striking new theory";
Seed Magazine(sponsor of Pinker at 92y.org):"Succeeds in illuminating how
fundamental differences between male and female thinking can be blamed on that
single, scrawny Y";
Deborah Blum, author of Sex on the Brain;
Nature;
Newsweek.
2) Tama Janowitz, Peyton Amberg.
3)Homosexuality and Civilization by Louis Crompton(Harvard University Press).
4)television series, "10-8," episode, "Gun of a Son,"
http://www.edge.org/documents/archive/edge160.html
|